Caleb has spent a year in juvenile detention for hitting his sister’s best friend with his car. It was a hit and run accident, and Maggie had to go to years of physical therapy because of it. Life after the hit-and-run has been tough for her. She is shocked when Caleb comes back to Paradise, but they feel an attraction to each other. But will Maggie ever be able to forgive Caleb for hitting her with his car?